SEASON HAMMER OF THE YEAR RUNNER-UP
2011/12 MARK NOBLE JAMES TOMKINS
2010/11 SCOTT PARKER ROBERT GREEN
2009/10 SCOTT PARKER ALESSANDRO DIAMANTI
2008/09 SCOTT PARKER ROBERT GREEN
2007/08 ROBERT GREEN GEORGE MCCARTNEY
2006/07 CARLOS TEVEZ BOBBY ZAMORA
2005/06 DANNY GABBIDON MARLON HAREWOOD
2004/05 TEDDY SHERINGHAM MARK NOBLE
2003/04 MATTHEW ETHERINGTON MICHAEL CARRICK
2002/03 JOE COLE JERMAIN DEFOE
2001/02 SEBASTIEN SCHEMMEL DAVID JAMES
2000/01 STUART PEARCE PAOLO DI CANIO
1999/00 PAOLO DI CANIO TREVOR SINCLAIR
1998/99 SHAKA HISLOP IAN PEARCE
1997/98 RIO FERDINAND STEVE LOMAS
1996/97 JULIAN DICKS SLAVEN BILIC
1995/96 JULIAN DICKS IAIN DOWIE
1994/95 STEVE POTTS TONY COTTEE
1993/94 TREVOR MORLEY STEVE POTTS
1992/93 STEVE POTTS KEVIN KEEN
1991/92 JULIAN DICKS STEVE POTTS
1990/91 LUDEK MIKLOSKO GEORGE PARRIS
1989/90 JULIAN DICKS STUART SLATER
1988/89 PAUL INCE JULIAN DICKS
1987/88 STEWART ROBSON BILLY BONDS
1986/87 BILLY BONDS MARK WARD
1985/86 TONY COTTEE FRANK McAVENNIE
1984/85 PAUL ALLEN TONY COTTEE
1983/84 TREVOR BROOKING TONY COTTEE
1982/83 ALVIN MARTIN PHIL PARKES
1981/82 ALVIN MARTIN TREVOR BROOKING
1980/81 PHIL PARKES GEOFF PIKE
1979/80 ALVIN MARTIN RAY STEWART
1978/79 ALAN DEVONSHIRE BRYAN ROBSON
1977/78 TREVOR BROOKING
1976/77 TREVOR BROOKING ALAN DEVONSHIRE
1975/76

TREVOR BROOKING GRAHAM PADDON
1974/75 BILLY BONDS MERVYN DAY
1973/74 BILLY BONDS MERVYN DAY
1972/73 BRYAN ROBSON TREVOR BROOKING
1971/72 TREVOR BROOKING BOBBY FERGUSON
1970/71 BILLY BONDS BOBBY MOORE
1969/70 BOBBY MOORE BILLY BONDS
1968/69 GEOFF HURST BILLY BONDS
1967/68 BOBBY MOORE TREVOR BROOKING
1966/67 GEOFF HURST BOBBY MOORE
1965/66 GEOFF HURST MARTIN PETERS
1964/65 MARTIN PETERS BOBBY MOORE
1963/64 JOHNNY BYRNE BOBBY MOORE
1962/63 BOBBY MOORE JIM STANDEN
1961/62 LAWRIE LESLIE JOHN DICK
1960/61 BOBBY MOORE
1959/60 MALCOLM MUSGROVE
1958/59 KEN BROWN
1957/58 ANDY MALCOLM